Review of "Galactica Discovers Earth, Part 1, Episode 1 of Galactica 1980"
Review of
Galactica Discovers Earth, Part 1, Episode
1 of Galactica 1980
Three out of five stars
Some good points, but inherent weakness
Like many
others, I was extremely disappointed when the television series “Battlestar
Galactica” was cancelled after one season. While I questioned many of the absurd
plot points, the general trend of the series was entertaining. Therefore, I was
pleased when I viewed the promos for the reboot called “Galactica 1980.”
The time is
many years after the destruction of the colonies where the Galactica led the
survivors on a trek for Earth. The premise is that the fleet has encountered
Earth, but a powerful Cylon force is close behind. Once it is clear that Earth
is well behind the colonies in technology, rather than proceed to Earth and put
it in danger, the decision is made to veer off and send small teams to Earth with
the goal being to accelerate the pace of technological advancement. This introduces
the first major plot hole, for the Cylons would be capable of intercepting
broadcast transmissions from Earth and realize that it is populated by humans.
The
introduction of the genius Dr. Zee is an interesting point, for it introduces
the concept of a tactical wizard that can help even the odds between the humans
and Cylons. The story follows two warriors, Troy and Dillon that are sent to
Earth to make contact with a renowned nuclear physicist and help him solve the
problems associated with nuclear power. The contact takes place in southern
California.
There are
several attempts at humor where Troy and Dillon demonstrate a lack of
understanding of basic concepts of human behaviors. Some work while many do
not. It also demonstrates another plot flaw, for a genius at the level of Dr.
Zee would have created briefing materials for the warriors that would help them
avoid some of the misunderstandings.
Despite these
weaknesses, the episode has enough good points that it instills hope in the
viewer that the series will improve over future episodes as the characters and
their roles are fleshed out. The introduction of the female reporter Jamie
Hamilton shows a lot of promise as she is smart and adaptable.
Comments
Post a Comment